• Home
  • Blog
  • Mac Attack
  • Photo/Gear
  • More Apple
  • Den/HT
  • Essentials
  UofMTiger Tech
UOFMTIGER'S DEN

The New AppleTV:  Why not 4k?  

9/13/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture

The New AppleTV:  4k or not 4k? That is the question.

The long awaited AppleTV 4(th generation) has been announced.  The biggest and most obvious thing missing was 4k capabilities.  I have seen arguments for and against 4k, and I thought I would address some of the arguments against it in this post.

No one owns a 4k television

Is Apple a company that sits and waits for a future technology to be popular before they adopt it?

Let's just look at a bit of their history:

1.  MacBook - how many people owned USB-C before they made this the only none headphone port on thus computer?

2.  Thunderbolt/FireWire - don't tell me these were ever mainstream.

3.  Tablets - where was the large tablet market when the iPad was introduced?

It is obvious that Apple is usually the company that kicks us in the behind and tells us to move on to bigger and better things.  

There is no 4k content

There isn't a ton of 4 k content on the commercial market, unless you count YouTube, that I agree with.  However, content follows the technology.  When I bought my very first 1080i HDTV ( a huge 57 inch Hitachi console TV), about the only thing to watch with it was "Hogan's Heroes" reruns on HDNET.  If equipment makers had sat around waiting for content, we would still be be watching old standard def programming.   If Apple supported 4k with this box, they would push the studios to provide more content.
Picture

There is no benefit to 4k

That is the worst argument.  I saw the same argument about HDTV and Blu-Ray.  Let's be clear, more pixels equals more detail.  Yeah, if you sit too far away to see the extra resolution, then the benefits shrink.  However, that has always been the case. It is one of the reasons many people have 65 inch TVs instead of 27 inch TVs these days.  

To quote Apple:

"The 27‑inch iMac with Retina 5K display has four times as many pixels as the standard 27‑inch iMac display. So you experience unbelievable detail. On an unbelievable scale."

As you can see from the Apple photo below, 4k represents a huge benefit over 1080p.

Picture

Apple simply isn't ready for 4k yet

The amazing thing is that they are already touting 4k video for their new iPhone 6s.  To quote Apple:

"It takes brilliant 4K video, up to four times the resolution of 1080p HD video"

4k video recording will already be part of Apple's best selling consumer item by the time the AppleTV 4 hits the market.   So are these "brilliant 4k videos" supposed to only be seen on 27 inch iMac displays or would it make more sense to enable us to watch them on the much larger displays in our living rooms?  

4k is too expensive to implement at under $200

That would make sense if it wasn't for the fact that the Nvidia Shield does 4k in a similar device for less than $200.  In fact, it comes with a gaming remote with a headphone port, 2 USB3 inputs for adding devices like cameras and external drives, has 24/192 high resolution audio included, and 3GBs of RAM.  It has Google Voice search, an App Store, and does more than the new AppleTV.  

The only place they cut corners is that they only provided 16GB of storage, where the AppleTV at the same price has 64GB.  However, that is countered with the fact that the Nvidia has a microSD slot that can provide more onboard storage for games and movies.  As an example, Apple sells the 64GB AppleTV for $50 more than the 32GB version.  For around $20 you could add 64GB to the onboard 16GBs (giving you 80GB of storage).   That makes it slightly more expensive if you need exactly 64GBs, but it scales up nicely because you could add a 128GB card to it later when you need it.  With Apple, you are stuck with 64GB until you buy a new AppleTV.

In any event, if Nvidia can offer all that at $200, Apple should be able to offer it even cheaper thanks to the economies of scale.  Note: Since I wrote this article, Amazon has announced a new 4k FireTV  and Alexa that costs...wait for it.....$99!  
Picture

So why isn't there an AppleTV 4k?

That is the 4 million dollar question.  If I were to speculate, my guess is that there are two reasons. 

The first is that Apple likes large margins.  It isn't that they could not make a profit by offering a 4k AppleTV at $200.  It is that they have a formula that says they need to make X amount on every unit sold or it isn't worth their time. 
Picture
The second reason is to give them an obvious upgrade path. It is the equivalent of not including a camera in the first iPad or a speaker in the first iPod Touch.  Apple, in this area, isn't trying to push us to 4k because they have no dog in that fight.  If they had a 4k TV, they would be more interested.  In a year or two, don't be surprised if Tim Cook gets up on stage and tells us about the magical, brilliant detail offered  with their new 4k AppleTV.  
Picture

You must hate Apple or be an Android Fanboy

Nope, I own several AppleTVs and love the platform (see my article "In the Defense of the AppleTV" for proof).  In fact, I may end up buying one of the 4th gen models down the road if new apps are added that take advantage of Homekit or integrate in a compelling way with iOS.   

It is nice that they gave it a spec bump and Siri ( although I would have preferred it to be implemented in a way that made it more similar to the Amazon Echo, but that is an article for another day).  I also look forward to seeing the new apps that developers come up with.
Picture

Final Thoughts

It may surprise you, but I don't currently own an 4K HDTV.  Right now, I own a 32 inch, 4k monitor, though.  Unfortunately, at this point, I don't even own a 4k video source to push to the display.  I plan to get a new laptop next year when Skylake (that has USB-C / Thunderbolt 3 that will drive two 4k displays simultaneously) is available.  In other words, I am buying things now to prepare for the obvious 4k change that is coming.   I don't update tech every year, so I always try to plan ahead.

To that end, I waited for Apple's announcement, and since the AppleTV does not support 4k, I went ahead and ordered the Nvidia Shield (it was just delivered, so I will review it soon).  I will run it with my 4k monitor until I get the new laptop, and at that time, I will put it in with my 1080p living room system (one of the benefits of having advanced specs is that they are backwards compatible).  Then when there is enough content, I will update my living room TV.   

As I mentioned, I may also end up with a new AppleTV, 4 but I want to wait and see what it can offer me that I can't get with the combination of the AppleTV 3 and the Nvidia Shield.  Right now, nothing I saw in the demonstration is thrilling me, but the spec jump and Siri alone may be enough to sway me since I use so many Apple devices and anything that expands that ecosystem and makes it more user friendly has to be considered.   
0 Comments

    About me:

    Dog loving, Big Green Egg worshiping, Tech enthusiast, residing in Memphis, TN.  Home of the Tigers, Grizzlies, Elvis, Al Green, Stax, Hi Records, Ardent Studios, Beale Street, Peabody Ducks, etc..  I have also added the Jeep Wrangler to the list of things I am enthusiastic about.

    Archives

    July 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011

    Flickr pics below

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    135i Convertible
    16GB RAM MBP
    1 Series
    2010 Mac Mini For Media
    2011 MBP Dock
    2016 MBP
    2016 Office Tour
    2018 Mac
    328i Convertible
    3gs
    3rd Generation Ipad
    3rd Gen Ipad
    3 Series
    413j
    4K Dock
    4k FireTV
    4k Media Streaming
    4k TV
    4s
    5d Mark Iii
    5d Mark Iii Vs Nikon D800
    5d Mkiii
    5 Inch Iphone
    7 Cities Album Review
    85mm Review For Sony
    Air Display
    Airfoil
    Airfoil Speakers
    Airfoil With Echo
    Airfol
    AirMusic Player
    Airplay
    Airplay 2
    Airplay Mirroring
    Airplay Watch
    Airport Express
    Airport Express Airplay
    Alexa
    Alienware M15 R4
    Amazon
    Amazon Echo Dot
    Amazon Echo Dot Review
    Amazon Prime
    Angels Horn
    Angels Horn Review
    Anova Bluetooth Review
    Anova Precision Cooker
    Anova Suos Vide
    App
    Appel Watch
    Apple
    Apple And Sonos
    Apple Cinema Display
    Apple Has Awful Customer Service
    Apple Headphone Jack
    Apple HomePod
    Apple Is Doomed
    Apple LIghtning To USB Adapter
    Apple Lossless
    Apple Mac
    Apple Music
    Apple-music
    Apple-music-app-of-the-year
    Apple Music Beta IOS 10
    Apple Music Beta On IPad
    Apple Music Lossless
    Apple Music Mastered For ITunes
    Apple Music - Mastered For ITunes
    Apple Music Mastered For ITunes
    Apple Music Matching
    Apple Music Preview IOS10
    Apple Music Review
    Apple Music Siri
    Apple Music Suggestions
    Apple Music Watch
    Apple Music Wishlist
    Apple's Customer Service Is A Joke
    Apple Spartan
    AppleTV
    Apple Tv2 Airplay
    Apple TV 3rd Gen
    Appletv 4
    AppleTV 4 And Airplay 2
    AppleTV 4th Gen Review
    AppleTV 4 Wishlist
    AppleTV Wishlist
    Apple Watch
    Apple Watch 1 Year
    Apple Watch As Remote
    Apple Watch December 2015
    Apple Watch Review
    Apple Watch Vs Mechanical Watch
    Apple Watch With Airplay
    Apple Wishlist
    Apple Wishlist 2016
    Apps
    Arlo Q Review
    Arlo Wireless Review
    Audio
    Audiophile Reviews
    Audioquest Dragonfly Review
    Audiotap App
    Audirvana
    Audyssey
    Backups
    Backyard Cooking
    Bakersfield Review
    Battery Power
    BBQ
    BBQ Guru DigiQ Review
    Beats Music
    Beats Music IOS
    Beats Music Review
    Best Cloud Services
    Best IOS Apps 2015
    Best IPad Apps (2015)
    Best IPhone Apps Of The Year
    Best Office Setup
    Best Sounding Bluetooth
    Best Tech
    Best Tech 2021
    Best Web Services
    BFG KO2
    Bge
    Bge Table
    Big Green Egg
    Birsket On The BGE
    Black Rapid
    Bluetooth
    Bluetooth Headphones
    Bluettooth Headphones
    Bmw
    Bmw Apps
    Bourbon Decanter
    Brisket
    Brisket On The Big Green Egg
    Brisket Pizza
    Cablecard
    Camptune
    Canon
    Canon F4 Zooms
    Canon Wishlist 2016
    Canon Zooms
    Cars
    Case With Bluetooth Keyboard For IPad
    Case With Keyboard For IPad Air 2
    Ceramic Grill Store
    Charge IPad While Using DAC
    Cheap HiRES
    Checklist For Sous Vide
    Christmas Ideas 2021
    Chromecast Audio
    Chromecast Vs Airplay
    ClipR
    Clockology
    Cluttered Home Office
    Coach Pastner
    Consumer Reports
    Convertible Laptop
    Cool Tools - A Catalog Of Possibilities Review
    Cool Tools Book Review
    Crashplan+ Family Plan
    Crashplan Review
    Crashplan+ Review
    Crashplan Seed Review
    Crazy Room Setup Video
    Cuisinart
    Cuisinart ICE-21 Review
    DAC
    Denon
    Denon 4311CI
    Design Trends That Aren't Practical
    Desk Tour
    Desk Update
    DigiQ For BGE
    Directv Genie
    DLNA
    Dog Anxiety
    Dog Gadget
    Dog Tech
    Dog Thunderstorm Solutions
    Dragonfly DAC
    Dragonfly DAC With IPhone 6 Plus
    Dragonfly Usb Dac
    Dragon Glasses
    Drone
    Ds413j
    Earbuds
    Echo Dot For Music
    El Capitan Install Problem
    Elgato Dock Review
    Elgato Thunderbolt 2 Dock Review
    Elliptical
    E Pl5
    E-pl5
    Epson 2040 Review
    Ergotron MX Mount
    Extending Wifi
    F4 Preference
    Ff Vs M43
    Fidelia
    Fix El Capitan Install Issue
    Full Frame Vs Miro Four Thirds
    Gadget Backpack
    Gaming Projector
    George Foreman Grill
    Gps App
    Grill
    Grilling
    Grilling Out With A Griddle
    Harken Hoister
    Hdmi To Ethernet
    Headlamp
    Headphones
    Headphone Stand
    Headphone Stand Review
    Heed CanAmp
    Hi Rez Music Overrated
    Hi Rez Vs Redbook Audio
    Home Design Ideas
    Home Office
    Home-plug-and-airplay
    Homepod
    Homepod-compared
    Homepod-review
    Homepod-review
    Homepod-with-echo
    Homepod-with-j-river
    Homepod-with-plex
    Home-surveillance
    Home Theater
    Hot
    Hot85a534125d
    How-to-use-that-old-iphone
    Hp-4k-display-review
    Hp-spectre-32inch-studio-display-ledlit-monitor-review
    Hue-lights
    Huge-bluetooth-speaker
    Imac
    Imac-ssd-thunderbolt-upgrade
    Imac-ssd-thunderbolt-upgrade
    Imac-thunderbolt-2-dock-review
    Imac-with-second-monitor
    In Defense Of Tim Tebow
    Inexpensive Home Theater
    Inexpensive-home-theater
    Intuos 4
    Ios
    Ios-10
    Ios-lightroom
    Ios-multiple-room-airplay
    Iososx-hybrid
    Ios-remote
    Ipad
    Ipad2
    Ipad 3
    Ipad Accessory
    IPad Air 2
    IPad Air 2
    Ipad-air-2
    Ipad-air-2-audio
    Ipad-air-2-vs-ipad-3
    Ipad-apps
    Ipad Battery
    Ipad-battery-pack
    Ipad Battery Running Slingbox
    Ipad-bluetooth-keyboard
    Ipad-case
    Ipad Consumer Reports
    IPad Desktop
    Ipad Doesn
    Ipad Hot
    Ipad-kelbyone
    Ipad Killer
    Ipad-lightroom-app
    Ipad-lyndacom
    IPad M1
    Ipad Mini
    IPadOS
    Ipad-photography
    Ipad-pro-97
    Ipad-pro-97-review
    Ipad-pro-97-vs-ipad-air-2
    Ipads Fatal Flaw9e14764628
    IPad Vs Mac
    Ipad Warm
    IPhone
    Iphone 4s
    Iphone 5
    Iphone-6-plus
    Iphone-6-plus
    Iphone-6-plus-case
    Iphone-6-plus-inexpensive-case
    Iphone-6-plus-in-hand
    Iphone-6-plus-review
    Iphone-6splus-best-accessorires
    Iphone-7-plus
    Iphone-7-plus-jet-black
    Iphone-7-plus-review
    Iphone-accessories
    Iphone Airplay
    Iphone-apps
    Iphone-apps-2015
    Iphone-battery-pack
    Iphone Case
    IPhone Headphone Jack
    IPhone X
    Is Apple Music Perfect?
    Is Hi Rez Worth It?
    ITunes
    ITunes Lossless
    Jazz - Mastered For ITunes
    Jazzradio Airplay
    Jeep
    Jeep Accessories
    Jeep Cabin Curtain
    Jeep Cargo Cover
    Jeep Wrangler Accesories
    JKU SeatCovers
    JKU Seat Covers
    JKU Updates
    J River Airplay
    J River With Echo
    Kelbyone Review
    Kettle-Q Review
    Kindle
    Kindle Fire
    KitchenAide Mixer
    Kohler Mirror
    Kurt Kinetic
    Lacie Drive
    Lending Service
    Lexi
    Lexi IOS App
    Lifeproof
    Lifeproof Case For Ipad
    Lifeproof Case For Ipad Review
    Lifeproof Case Review
    Lifeproof IPhone 4s
    Lightroom
    Lightroom Mobile
    Liquid Spirit Album Review
    Living Room
    Living Room Projector
    Lodge Cast Iron
    Lossless Audio
    Loudness Wars
    Lynda.com Review
    Lynda.com Vs Kelbyone
    M43
    Mac
    Mac Apps
    Macbook Pro
    Mac Mini
    Mac Mini Home Theater
    Mac Mini Living Room
    Mac Mini M1
    Mac Mini Media Maven
    Mac Mini Media Server
    Mac Mini Remote
    MacOS
    Magic Keyboard
    Make Any Headphones Wireless
    Marantz 2220b
    Mastered For ITunes
    Maverick Et732
    Mbp
    Mbp Accessory
    MBP Mid-2011 SSD Upgrade
    Mbpr
    MBP SSD Update
    Melophobia Review
    Memphis Basketball
    Modernize
    MOG
    Mog Airplay
    Mountain Lion
    Mountains Of Sorrow
    Mount IPad To Mac
    Movie Streaming
    Multiroom Airplay Audio
    Music
    Music Streaming
    Nas Vs External Hard Drive
    Netgear Router
    New Ipad
    New Ipad Hot
    New Ipad Review
    New Ipad Tests
    New Year Resolutions For Tech 2015
    Nfl Tebow
    Ninja Blender Review
    Ninja Dough
    Ninja For Pizza
    Ninja Mega System Review
    Noise Cancelling Headphones
    Nvidia Shield
    Nvidia Shield Review
    Nyne Cruiser
    Office Setup 2016
    Old IPad
    Olympus E Pl5
    Olympus E-PL5
    Olympus E-PL5 Neck Strap Review
    Olympus With Canon Adapter
    Online Backup Review
    Online Photography
    Orbi Modem
    Orbi Wifi
    Original Ipad Vs New Ipad
    OSX Apps
    Outdoor Cooking
    Overrated Home Design Ideas
    PA2V2 Headphone Amp
    Parrot Anafi
    Parrot Zik 2.0 Headphones
    Parrot ZIk App
    Pcworld Has A Messed Up Ipad
    Pcworld Ipad 3 Battery
    PDP Pixel Pal Ren And Stimpu
    PDP Pixel Pals
    Petzl Tikka Improved Lumen Output Xp 2 Headlamp
    Phone 6 Plus Video
    Photo Airplay
    Photography
    Photography Classes On The Ipad
    Photography Videos For The Ipad
    Photography Videos On The Iphone
    Pixel Art
    Pizza
    Pizza On The Big Green Egg
    Plex
    Plugable USB Hub
    Plugbug
    Portable Hard Drive
    Portable HD Projector
    Portable SD Reader
    Power Bank
    Power Dots
    Power Line Ethernet
    Powerline Ethernet
    Powerline Ethernet And Airplay
    Projector
    Projector Setup
    Pulsar
    Pure I20
    Random Tech
    Rdio
    Rdio Is Best
    Regear To 4.88
    Remote Control App
    Repartition Bootcamp
    Retina
    Ring Doorbell Review
    Rivers Of Song Review
    Rock Music: Mastered For ITunes
    Roku
    Roku 4 - Best 4k Option
    Roku 4 Review
    Roku 4 Vs Nvidia Shield
    Roomie Remote App
    Roomie Remote Review
    Rugged Case
    Samsung 840 EVO MBP
    Samsung UltraWide
    Seagate Backup Plus Desktop Thunderbolt Adapter
    Seagate Desktop Thunderbolt Adapter
    Security Camera
    Setup Video
    Shiatsu
    Shure
    Shure 940
    Shure Sh940
    Shure SRH940s
    Simple Control
    Simple Control App With Echo
    Simple Control - Voice
    SimpleControl Watch
    Siri
    Siri And Apple Music
    Siriusxm
    Siri With Apple Music
    Sitting Exercise
    Smarthome
    Smartplugs
    Smoked Brisket
    Smokeware SS Vented Chimney Cap
    Sonos
    Sonos Connect
    Sonos Or Airport Express
    Sonos Vs Airplay
    Sonos Vs Mac Mini
    Sony A7 Lens
    Sony Bluetooth
    Sony Camera
    Soundsource
    Southeastern Album Review
    Speaker For Biking
    Spotify
    Srh940
    Srh940414fd02963
    Ssd-portable-drive
    Standing Desk
    Steelseries-siberia-elite-prism
    Stepper
    Stereo
    Stero
    Stir Fry
    Streaming Itunes To Iphone
    Streaming-music-is-it-for-you
    Streaming Music To Itunes
    Superchips
    Sweet Mac Setups
    Synology
    Synology Nas
    T3Hub Substitute
    Tech
    Tech Backpack
    Tech Gadget Bag
    Tech GIfts
    Tech Wishlist
    Tech Wishlist 2016
    Ten Best Apps For Mac
    Terflex 2.5 Lift
    T-Fal Skillet
    The Most Advanced Headphones In The World
    Thunderbolt
    Thunderbolt 2 Dock
    Thunderbolt 3
    Thundershirt
    Thundrebolt
    Tidal
    Tidal Review
    Tim Tebow
    Tivo Bolt
    Tivo Bolt Review
    Tivo Mini
    Top IPad Apps
    Top Jeep Accessories
    Top Tech 2018
    Top Tech 2021
    Top Tech List 2015
    Top Tech Of The Year
    Top Ten Albums 2013
    Top Ten Apps For Web Services
    Top Ten Cloud Apps
    Top Ten IPad Apps
    Top Ten Tech
    Top Ten Tech 2012
    Top Ten Tech 2013
    Top Ten Tech 2105
    Toshiba Convertible Review
    Toshiba Laptop Review 2016
    Toshiba Satellite Fusion 15 Review
    TP-Link RE200 AC750
    Travel Tech Bag
    Trektop NX
    Tripod Projector Screen
    Tuffty Security
    Turntable
    Turntable Review
    TV Sound To Headphones
    Ultimate Mac Office
    Ultimate Office For Music
    Ultimate Office Setup 2015
    Ultimate Setup 2016
    UltraHD 32 Inch Monitor Review
    Unvarnished Album Review
    Uofmtiger Photography
    Uofmtiger's Mac Attack
    Uplift Desk
    USB-C
    USB SSD
    USB Turntable
    Use This
    Vacation Tech
    Vehicle Cupholder Mount For 6 Plus
    Victorinox Knife
    Videogear
    Vintage Receiver
    Vitasound PAE-200 Review
    Vudu
    Vudu Disc To Digital Review
    WHAALE App
    What Is A Pro Laptop?
    What They Use
    Whiskey Glasses
    Why Apple Music Will Succeed
    Why I Chose The 5d Mark Iii
    Wifi
    WiiM
    WiiM Airplay 2
    Wiim Audirvana
    WiiM Hi Res
    Wiim Hi Res Update
    Wiim Mini 24/192
    WiiM Update
    Wiim UPNP
    Wild Feathers Review
    Willie Sugarcapps Review
    Windows And Mac Video Setup
    Wired Airplay
    Wired Airport Express
    Wireless Security Cam
    Wok
    Work Stations
    World Boogie Is Coming Review
    Wrangler Accessories
    Wwdc Review
    Zoom Modem
    Zuli Review
    ZyXel 600mbps Powerline AV2 Gigabit Adapter ZyXel 600mbps Powerline AV2 Gigabit Adapter